Skip to content
Network For Animals Logo
Network For Animals Logo
  • How we take action
    • Cats In Crisis
    • Disaster Relief
    • Dogs In Distress
    • Donkey and Equine Care and Rescue
    • Ukraine War
  • News
  • About
    • Meet Our Team
    • Financials
    • Testimonials
  • Contact
  • Donate
  • How we take action
    • Cats In Crisis
    • Disaster Relief
    • Dogs In Distress
    • Donkey and Equine Care and Rescue
    • Ukraine War
  • News
  • About
    • Meet Our Team
    • Financials
    • Testimonials
  • Contact
  • Donate
Donate now
  • How we take action
    • Cats In Crisis
    • Disaster Relief
    • Dogs In Distress
    • Donkey and Equine Care and Rescue
    • Ukraine War
  • News
  • About
    • Meet Our Team
    • Financials
    • Testimonials
  • Contact
  • Donate
Menu
  • How we take action
    • Cats In Crisis
    • Disaster Relief
    • Dogs In Distress
    • Donkey and Equine Care and Rescue
    • Ukraine War
  • News
  • About
    • Meet Our Team
    • Financials
    • Testimonials
  • Contact
  • Donate

Godfray Review shifts focus from badgers to farmers

  • November 15, 2018
  • United Kingdom

An independent review of the United Kingdom’s controversial bovine tuberculosis (bTB) strategy, has shifted the blame for the spread of the disease from badgers to farmers.

The much-anticipated Bovine TB Strategy Review was published today. One of its key findings is that there is “disappointingly low” uptake of basic biosecurity measures to limit the spread of bTB that costs UK taxpayers £100-million (USD130-million) in compensation every year.

“In particular, the poor take up of on-farm biosecurity measures and the extent of trading in often high-risk cattle is, we believe, severely hampering disease control,” it said.

The author of the Review, Sir Charles Godfray, professor of zoology at Oxford University was quoted in The Independent as saying:

“If I had to say more one than the other it’s definitely more on the cattle to cattle side (than badger to cattle infection). We realise that wildlife does have a role in this disease, but it’s wrong to put all the blame on wildlife and to use this as an excuse to not make hard decisions in industry, which is going to cost the industry money.”

The report says that the controversy surrounding the badger cull has had the “unfortunate consequence of … deflecting focus from what can be done by the individual farmer and livestock community”.

Among the measures that could be taken to control the spread of bTB are keeping neighbouring herds separate to prevent the tuberculosis bacteria passing from nose to nose contact, and preventing badgers from getting on to farms, particularly around feed bins.

Network for Animals is part of a groundswell of resistance to the culling of badgers which forms a major part of the UK’s bTB strategy. An estimated 75 000 badgers have already been killed – at a cost of £50-million (USD65-million) – often in ways that cause them to suffer long, slow and painful deaths.

“The findings of the Godfray Review underscore what we and our partner organisations have said all along: the badger cull is cruel, senseless and costly,” said David Barritt, chief campaigner for NFA.

“We intend to keep applying pressure on the UK government until it finally does what any responsible government must surely do under the circumstances: abandon its policy of killing badgers.”

Pressure is mounting

In recent weeks, pressure has mounted on the UK’s Department of Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra) to admit that its policy of killing badgers is not working.

Yesterday, in a strongly worded letter to chief vet, Dr Christine Middlemiss, a group of veterinarians accused Defra of “telling barefaced lies” about the effectiveness of its badger culling policy. They were highly critical of comments made by Farming Minister, George Eustice, in September.

Eustice said: “Today’s figures showing reductions in TB cases in Somerset and Gloucestershire are evidence that our strategy for dealing with this slow-moving, insidious disease is delivering results.” However, the report he quotes from, compiled by Defra’s own scientists at the Animal and Plant Health Agency, explicitly states, “these data alone cannot demonstrate whether the badger control policy is effective in reducing bovine TB in cattle”.

One of the signatories of the letter, Dr Iain McGill, told BBC News that claims by Defra that the badger cull in Somerset and Gloucestershire were working were not supported by scientific evidence.

“According to Defra’s figures, they claim that they calculated that the incidence [of TB in cattle] has reduced. But their calculations are unclear and deliberately opaque. And, indeed, the current situation in the cull zone says there is an increased prevalence,” he said.

“So, either their figures were calculated on an extremely inaccurate basis and they’ve got it very badly wrong, or they have actually gerrymandered those figures to make it look as if the incidence is falling when the evidence clearly shows that the prevalence has gone up. Badger culling has not worked. They are issuing barefaced lies in this matter.”

The veterinarians’ letter marks the second time in a month that the veterinary and animal welfare community has spoken out strongly against the badger cull. On 21 October, Network for Animals chief executive officer, Gloria Davies, was one of 15 eminent veterinarians and animal welfare campaigners who addressed an open letter to Eustice, questioning the effectiveness of the badger cull.

The letter was published in part by The Guardian and in full by the respected scientific journal, VetRecord.

According to a Defra statement, the Godfray Review is “now with the Ministers who will consider its recommendations before publishing a response setting out the next steps for the bTB strategy.”

By supporting our work, you are reaching out with caring hands to stop animal abuse

Please donate now
Stay up to date

Stay up to date

Share link

“Miracle Dog” Who Survived 72 Days in the Colorado Mountains After her Owner’s Death is Recovering, had “Ravenous Appetite”

Article written by CBS News Originally published by CBS NEWS (Fri, Nov 17, 2023) A faithful dog who survived after spending more than 10 weeks by her

22 November 2023

Dogs Produce Tears when Reunited with Owners, Study Finds

Article written by Nicola Davis Originally published by The Guardian (Mon, Aug 22, 2023) Research is first to demonstrate positive emotion provoking tears in a

16 November 2023

South Korea to Ban Eating Dog Meat

Article written by SKY NEWS Originally published by sky news (Fri, Nov 17, 2023) The popularity of eating dog meat has fallen dramatically in South

12 November 2023

Spain: More than 400 Animals Rescued from Illegal Trading Network

Article written by Kathryn Armstrong Originally published by BBC (Wed, Oct 18, 2023) More than 400 animals, mainly cats and dogs, have been rescued from

8 November 2023

Help us fight cruelty to animals around the world

Click here to donate

Network for Animals

Network for Animals is a non-government, international animal welfare organization crusading for animals around the world.

© Network for Animals
Terms and conditions/ Privacy policy
Cookie policy

Campaigns

Cats In Crisis Disaster Relief Dogs In Distress Equine Care and Rescue Ukraine War Worldwide Donkey Crisis

Stay up to date

Receive our regular emails about our campaigns for animals around the world.

Sign up

Contact us

UK: +44 (0)20 8471 7666
USA: +1 727 599 8148
South Africa: 
+ 27 21 794 9149

info@networkforanimals.org

Facebook-f Twitter Youtube Instagram Linkedin
Donate
Subscribe

Sign up to our newsletter

enEnglish
af Afrikaans sqAlbanian amAmharic arArabic hyArmenian azAzerbaijani euBasque beBelarusian bnBengali bsBosnian bgBulgarian caCatalan cebCebuano nyChichewa zh-CNChinese (Simplified) zh-TWChinese (Traditional) coCorsican hrCroatian csCzech daDanish nlDutch enEnglish eoEsperanto etEstonian tlFilipino fiFinnish frFrench fyFrisian glGalician kaGeorgian deGerman elGreek guGujarati htHaitian Creole haHausa hawHawaiian iwHebrew hiHindi hmnHmong huHungarian isIcelandic igIgbo idIndonesian gaIrish itItalian jaJapanese jwJavanese knKannada kkKazakh kmKhmer koKorean kuKurdish (Kurmanji) kyKyrgyz loLao laLatin lvLatvian ltLithuanian lbLuxembourgish mkMacedonian mgMalagasy msMalay mlMalayalam mtMaltese miMaori mrMarathi mnMongolian myMyanmar (Burmese) neNepali noNorwegian psPashto faPersian plPolish ptPortuguese paPunjabi roRomanian ruRussian smSamoan gdScottish Gaelic srSerbian stSesotho snShona sdSindhi siSinhala skSlovak slSlovenian soSomali esSpanish suSudanese swSwahili svSwedish tgTajik taTamil teTelugu thThai trTurkish ukUkrainian urUrdu uzUzbek viVietnamese cyWelsh xhXhosa yiYiddish yoYoruba zuZulu

Lisa-Mari Spence

Leadership Gifts Officer

Lisa-Mari was raised in South Africa and joined the NFA team as the UK fundraiser after relocating to Greece. With a background in public relations and a passion for helping animals her role at NFA is a perfect match.

Alissa Ford

Director of Leadership Gifts, USA

Alissa is the Director of Leadership Gifts in the United States. She has a background in nonprofit fundraising and marketing, but believes all paths led her to Network for Animals, where she is able to combine her professional experience with her personal passion for animal welfare. Alissa lives in Boston, Massachusetts with her husband and her fur-baby Ollie, who is treated like the prince he thinks he is, since his human brother and sister are grown and now living on their own. Alissa loves speaking to our supporters who she truly considers a community of fellow animal lovers.